Prologue
It all started because we decided to extend the offer to participate in our webjam to a Melonland thread (archive). It was already populated by Agora Road users and people from hardcord. And the idea was something like...
"Agora and Melonland collaboration would be like Jews and Muslims collaboration"
It was a smashing success in that regard. Though Agorans outweighed Melonlanders in number, neither faction commented about the presence of the other and everyone was nice to each other and spoke highly of all the entries regardless of skill levels. The links to threads on both sites were displayed prominently at the top of the jam website.
I have a dream that one day, Melonlander boys and Agoran boys will walk hand in hand, that Melonlander girls and Agoran girls will stand side by side, and that neither shall look upon the other with suspicion, but with understanding.
Could such a thing be possible?
After the jam I had a renewed interest in exploring Melonland, a site which I had not used in a year or so. In that time many of its features had grown significantly. Melonland is a custom forum software but it's more than that; a variety of features are built on top of it using the same user accounts and auth. While there are many such features, the ones you need to understand to follow the story are the guilds and the everyone site (a feature which I've written about previously). Without any of these features, Melonland would not be as interesting of a playground as it is.
But while there are tons of cool new things to play with there's no escaping the same old bittersweet truth: an oppressive insistence on saccharine positivity and political correctness is suffocating and drives away everyone except perpetual victims, furries, and leftwing ideologues.
In the moderation guidelines (archive), it says:
"The audience is diverse. Various political values, world views, philosophies and religious views can coexist here; this means that there is no place for intolerance."
The last clause of the sentence reveals that the first statements are not true. You're already familiar with the type of people that use language like this and they're not tolerant of anything. But maybe the reason why one homogenous type of user with the same philosophy is pervasive on the site is because no one has come along who is willing to carve out their own space while being friendly with other people who are not like them.
Maybe all the types of people that I consider to be cool just leave (the same way I just left in the past) and the result is that Melonland is the way it is. After all Melon isn't a furry. He doesn't cry about his disabilities and mental disorders all day. Surely he didn't ask for such people to invade his site. He's just a nice guy who isn't willing to make them leave, but surely he wants better for his site than this.
Right? Right?
There's a quote on Melon's personal website that struck me.
"Hello humans, Im Daniel aka Melon aka the webmaster. I live on a distant rock called Ireland, here I make soup and look at the rain. hopefully you enjoy exploring my web-o-sphere. may it remind you that things do not have to be as they are."
The last line stuck with me and I thought, I can complain about Melonland, a site that I love some days and hate other days, or I could actually try to make it better. Melon is practically begging me to help him!
I uploaded this (archive) to the HalfMoon Art Hub, where on any given day you can see how diverse the community is.
The post was up and active on the site for weeks. They didn't moderate it out until after I had been banned.
But this was an expression of how I was feeling; that we could come to Melonland and just be present. Melon would tolerate us the same way he tolerates the furs. All we have to do is follow the rules and not insult people while expressing ourselves.
But who are we exactly? The original idea was just a group for regular nerdy dudes. CHUDs. Whatever you want to call it. The Melonland guilds feature already supports gathering specific users together and organizing them.
So that's what we needed: a guild for CHUDs...
And we are adding some of our own additions to the Glegle page.
This is a story that will unfold in two parts. In the first part, I was not trying to get banned although I knew it was a likely possibility. My gambit was that I could make Melonland better if I could thread the needle between following the rules and being based. If I could improve the site while also demonstrating to others how it's possible, perhaps Melon would accept a shift in the Overton window and other cool people would emerge from the site. I considered it unlikely but worth it to find out, with the worst case scenario being that we would know with certainty that Melonland is never going to be better.
In the second part we find out. :P
Part I: The Guild
The Chivalric House of United Defenders
It started with the creation of the Defender guild (archive). This page has been unlisted from the guilds and I suspect that like many other pages will eventually disappear. While at the time of writing this you can still technically access it, there's no use trying to join it, as it's by approval, and the guild admin user (archive) is secretly banned.
Most likely any attempt to interact with this guild or mentioning it at all will result in you getting banned.
At this stage the goals of the guild was just to identify and gather our type of people in one space while making it known to the user base that we exist by uploading art, artifacts, and user profiles that don't match the typical thing you find.
Introduce Based Ideas to Existing Threads
There were a few threads where I tried to show how to do this. The MO was not to post threads about based subjects but to introduce based ideas to existing threads.
- Based Presence in Anti-Tradition Thread (archive)
- Diagnosing Friend With Retardation Thread (archive)
- Sad that Bioware is Shutting Down Thread (archive)
The first thread is the perfect way to do it: Express oppositional view points while being completely friendly and positive and not upset at all that other people have the complete opposite view.
The second thread isn't terrible but I messed up a bit with that and my message was edited by moderators. This is a great example of how careful you have to be when expressing dissent.
The third thread is a case where I found a like-minded user. You can see that he was moderated for his post. Of course I invited him to the guild.
This is ultimately the goal. You're not trying to trigger the people that don't agree with you. You're trying to prompt people that do agree with you to speak up. And when you find them, you would invite them to the guild.
Introduce Based Ideas to User Profile
I linked my profile (archive) above but I'll talk about it a bit more.
This was (like the threads) intended to be a template for how to boldly proclaim an atypical viewpoint while also being charitable to those people with the opposite view point.
In addition the profile served as a call to improve the site by uploading things that don't fall into furry fandom and thanks to anyone who tries something different regardless of their skill level.
Improve the Website
The guild wasn't supposed to just be about being based all the time. It was about actively uploading cool art, artifacts, making everyone site updates, and just showing people what it looks like when there are themes other than how gay and disabled you are. It would speak for itself. Other people, even the gay and disabled people, would start wanting to post better contributions. Our value as a guild would be self evident.
Claim Improvements in the Name of the Guild
So with that, you pretty much understand the guild and what its goals were.
Now let's talk about our greatest achievement.
The Guild Goes to the Moon
Originally the Moon on Melonland was just a page with a picture of the moon that links to another page. One of our members got the idea to turn it into a "biome" like the village, the forest, the desert, etc.
The first version was pretty simple.
The final version is probably the most attractive biome page.
We initially claimed it for the the guild like this but decided taking up four spaces was not necessary.
We settled on the one above and added the biome to the explore nav to ensure it would be a staple of the site.
The Guild eSite Page
Conquering the Moon and putting our logo there was an entry point for the guild site, a series of pages anyone in the guild could edit. I wasn't really sure what to put there and so it ended up just being these two images on a black background, intended to be a temporary page.
This audio was also looped.
Part II: The Ban
From the way this post is organized, it can seem like some of the things shown in screen shots happened chronologically or that one event immediately followed another event. In reality, claiming the moon was the first thing we did together. The improvements to the mall and some of the other stuff happened after that. These were edits that were live on the site for at least a couple weeks.
So the ban really did come out of no where.
The one thing I remember was that before I went to work I had randomly posted this on someone's new biome page.
I remember thinking it was really funny if this was the straw that broke the camel's back.
"Past Moderation Issues"
The only recent one is shown above already but again below.
In this example you can see that my post was considered okay with a slight edit to my wording which I assented and agreed to.
I'm not saying that there was never a moderation issue before this, as I have had a Melonland account for years now. I used it quite a bit when I first made it and then left it dormant for a long time such that I don't remember every detail of the past. It's possible that there is some similar minor infraction like this. But I know with certainty that there's nothing major.
Why I'm Banned
It's my recent activity shown in this post which is not explicitly against the rules.
It's the "after receiving repeated complaints" part that is truly why I'm banned. For the weeks that we were doing this, the mods were dealing with my every action being reported and having to conclude that I wasn't breaking the rules. Otherwise I would have just been moderated -- they love to nickel and dime you about every slight choice of word so if they found something to comment about they would have. They didn't give me leeway because they wanted to. They gave me leeway because I was precisely following the rules.
It was only when they decided they didn't want to deal with it that they simply disappeared me. I say it like that because there's no obvious sign that I'm banned. It looks more like I just got bored of the site and decided to stop using it.
In the moderation guidelines (archive), it says:
"Moderation should be as transparent as possible".
Why It's Still Completely Fair and There's No Hard Feelings
I knew exactly what I was doing. The website belongs to Melon and its his moderation staff that has to deal with people complaining about me. I knew what the user base is like. I knew that I was going on to their site with an ulterior motive to change the culture.
They could see what I was doing as clearly as I was laying it down and they decided that they don't want it. If I had gone into this not being fully prepared for this outcome, it would be absurd.
I still think Melon's a great artist. His website is a fun playground.
We don't have the same taste. That's all it is. I do wish him the best with his projec.
In addition to banning me, they start removing any sigs of the guild or any threads where we talk about the deeds of the guild.
Plot Twist: I Can Still Edit the eSite Even After Being Banned
TLDR is that even though I was banned, I could still edit the eSite pages from pad.php, which didn't know about the ban.
Me and the guild members talked it over about the potential for lulz. It was decided that there's no way to hide it or play a long game. It's either make use of it to do something funny or don't. The amount of time that I would have access to the flaw was most likely very limited.
I'd also like to point out that from beginning I intentionally set limits to what I was willing to do with the left over privilege. The idea was to keep it humorous and silly; don't do anything that's actually destructive or harmful.
But aside from that, beyond this point there is no longer any respect given to rules as far as the content of my posts.
Put the Guild Logo on Every Page and Restore the Guild Page
"Lucky CHUDs are such nice guys." The fact that I could have posted something much worse was really the theme of all the edits I did after being banned. At this stage I didn't realize just how many of them there would be.
When they discovered this they deleted the pages again and locked me out. IIRC they deleted more of my pages than the first time after this.
Plot Twist II: I Discover How to Restore My Usage of pad.php
TLDR is that whatever they did to take away my permissions to use pad.php, it wasn't sufficient to prevent me from getting it back. The way I discovered to do it (accidentally) was to just create a page with the logged in account's username. So pad.php?p=nobo and because the page doesn't exist, and I suppose because it saw that I'm the logged in user (even though banned), it creates the page, which provisions the permissions back to me.
But of course I knew we wouldn't be back for long. But I was amused and curious to see how long we would go back and forth between them deleting my pages and me putting more up. Eventually I gave up on putting the guild back on the moon and I started "tubgirl" posting.
Posting Tubgirl All Over Melonland
Sort of.
I didn't really do it. But the point was to say that I could have done it.
I made a page called tubgirl and put a stock photo of a normal girl on it.
Then I started putting links to the page on as many random pages as I could trying to force it to the top of the workshop list.
Hours later watching when the page got deleted, all the references to it still existed and had to be deleted as well.
Make "Do You Think About the Days" Song Play on Every Page
Random Corruptions
I knew that time was limited and that as soon as they woke up and discovered I was still editing pages it would probably be over.
The best use of the remaining time would be making as many small edits to as many pages as possible.
Gave Up Claiming the Moon for the CHUDs
Instead of putting the Defender guild link back up I decided to place a cathedral and link it to the Christian guild page, which I also created. I figured there is a small chance they will not take this edit out in order to avoid the accusation that they banned me for being Christian. Although they could take it out at any time, as of now it's still on the moon.
Other Services Available Despite Being Banned
Prior to me doing this, several other services including letters, main street, and banners were still available to use after being banned. Not anymore though. :P
A Gifted Artifact
Before any of this madness happened I was chatting with several users about how I wanted a memento mori skull but didn't think there was any ethical way to get one. In the midst of all this, someone gifted me a skull artifact. I'm not sure if they were saying, "Enjoy this while it lasts, your time here is almost over." Or were they completely oblivious and just remembering me and our chat conversation. As I've noted before, it's not obvious to Melonland users that I'm banned. And it's relatively likely that someone could be logged into the forum and not paying attention to the chaotic edits happening on the eSite. Even if they were looking at it, it wouldn't be clear that it was coming from a user who has been banned.
In any case, thanks for the gift. I had no way to respond to this but got the notification.
And when it was over, it was over.
It was the most fun I've ever had being banned.






































































